DALLAS, TX — The Dallas Cowboys‘ Round 2 draft selection of Eric Gilmore, a linebacker out of Texas A&M, has set the league abuzz—not for good reasons. Pegged as the 274th player in true value and graded with a glaring “D” by analysts, the Cowboys’ decision to pick Gilmore at 43rd overall is being labeled as a high-risk gamble.
The 6’2″, 253-pound linebacker boasts a “Power Rusher” archetype, but his scouting report paints a mixed picture. With average speed, limited play recognition, and a lack of threatening pass-rushing moves, Gilmore faces an uphill battle to prove himself worthy of his second-round status. However, he does have redeeming qualities, including a strong frame, decent awareness, and above-average stamina that may provide the coaching staff with a developmental project.
Scouting Breakdown
Gilmore’s scouting report highlights concerns that are hard to ignore:
- Average speed for a linebacker: Clocking in at 77 for speed and 88 for acceleration, Gilmore struggles to keep up with faster offenses.
- Limited impact plays: His block-shedding and power moves lack the explosiveness needed to disrupt plays consistently.
- Below-average coverage skills: With poor grades in both zone and man coverage, he’ll need significant improvement to contribute in pass defense.
On the upside, Gilmore’s solid pursuit and ability to fight through blockers suggest he could thrive in the right system—provided he’s given time to develop.
Reaction from the Cowboys Front Office
Cowboys owner Jerry Jones defended the pick, emphasizing Gilmore’s potential upside. “We see Eric as a player with untapped potential. Sure, he’s raw, but he’s a physical presence that can thrive with the right coaching,” said Jones. Head coach Andres Perez echoed this sentiment, adding, “He brings a certain toughness that we value on defense.”
Fan Reactions and League Opinions
Fans on social media were quick to criticize the selection, with many labeling it a “reach” or even “desperation.” Draft expert Marcus Reed was less harsh but still skeptical: “Gilmore has tools, but he was clearly overdrafted. This pick will come down to how patient the Cowboys are with his development.”
Others argue that the pick highlights a strategic flaw in Dallas’ draft approach, pointing to better-rated linebackers who were still available.
Path Forward
Eric Gilmore has much to prove if he’s to shake the “bust” label prematurely placed on him. While the Cowboys seem confident in their ability to develop him, the pressure will be on Gilmore to deliver in training camp and the preseason.
The Cowboys next face critical decisions as they fill out the rest of their draft board. Will Gilmore be the exception to the rule or another cautionary tale about draft gambles? Only time will tell.
